That's pretty good. I've got no quarrel with any of it.
I like the adult 'outward look at the world' focus vs YA inward character focus that she describes. I think that's a very clear difference with adult lit having teenage characters and a YA book. Very true.
This is one of the most logical genre definitions I've seen regarding YA. You're spot-on about inner-directed growth as a key feature.
this was awesome!BTW thanks for you sweet comment on my agent post - almost made me cry *sniff* ;)
This is a great list. As others said in the comments, I'd love to see a similar one for middle-grade, or a key to how MG novels differ from YA as defined in this list.There's content, obviously - if a faithful movie of the book would be rated above PG-13 for sex, violence, etc., then the book might not belong in MG - but I wonder whether it also relies on the difference in protagonist experience based on age. After all, a book might follow an eleven-year-old, focusing largely on her personal growth and using an active style as described here, but an eleven-year-old's personal growth might be different from a young teen's. (I'm thinking in particular about the wacky world of hormones.)That said, where does one put a series (the obvious example being Harry Potter) wherein the protagonist ages from child to teen over several books?
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner